Assistant Professor Wakana Oishi and Associate Professor Daijiro Mizutani of Tohoku University Graduate School, in collaboration with the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, have developed a new mathematical model to derive the optimal combination of centralized (sewerage) and decentralized (septic tank) wastewater treatment technologies.
The water and sewage infrastructure developed after the war is now reaching the end of its lifespan due to aging. Meanwhile, considering the declining population, it is anticipated that maintaining and updating the current scale of infrastructure will become increasingly difficult. Therefore, it is considered necessary to systematically downsize large-scale facilities and, in sparsely populated areas, transition to individual wastewater treatment systems such as septic tanks.
Against this backdrop, this study developed a new mathematical optimization model to quantitatively calculate the optimal combination ("best mix") of centralized (collective treatment) and decentralized (individual treatment) sewerage infrastructure. This model covers both cases: when existing sewerage systems are refurbished and maintained, and when they are decommissioned and converted to septic tanks. It can derive an optimal solution that simultaneously satisfies multiple conditions, such as minimizing renovation costs, maintenance costs, and greenhouse gas emissions over a 50-year period after renovation, while maximizing biogas recovery.
The analysis revealed that maintaining the current sewage treatment system would result in the highest total cost over 50 years. On the other hand, converting all households to septic tanks would reduce the total cost, but would increase greenhouse gas emissions associated with treatment at each household, thus raising the environmental burden.
In contrast, the "centralized and distributed best mix" derived through mathematical optimization revealed that it can simultaneously reduce both costs and environmental impact.
This research provides a pioneering quantitative demonstration of how to renew sewage infrastructure in a future where population decline is accelerating. It is expected that planned downsizing (reduction of large-scale infrastructure) and technology selection based on mathematical evidence will contribute to the construction of a sustainable and highly efficient sewage treatment system while maintaining safety and comfort.
Paper information: [Water Research] Adapting sanitation systems to demographic transitions: Optimizing hybrid configurations of sewered and non-sewered solutions

